Tea Time with Annie Kate Rotating Header Image

Review: Total Truth by Nancy Pearcey


total truth

Few books have been recommended to me as highly as Total Truth by Nancy Pearcey.  This book about Liberating Christianity from its Cultural Captivity more than lives up to its reputation.

I suppose the whole premise of Total Truth is summed up in this thought:  “Redemption is not just about being saved from sin, it is also about being saved to something—to resume the task for which we were originally created.”  And what was this task?  According to Genesis 1:28 our purpose is very simply  “to create cultures, build civilizations—nothing less,”  in other words, to develop all aspects of families, churches, schools, cities, governments, laws, agriculture, engineering, science, arts, and more.

Based on the idea that it is important to redeem the culture as well as individuals and that we need to move beyond a privatized faith, Total Truth aims to equip evangelical Christians with the conceptual tools they need to impact culture.  However, it is not a ‘how to’ book of political activism; instead it analyses our culture, showing why and how Christianity is marginalized and what we can do about it in our everyday lives.

North American society has developed a crippling way of looking at the world based on the idea that there are two aspects of life:

  • the value-based, private, subjective world of religion and feeling, and
  • the fact-based, public world of science, politics, and everyday life.

Notice that Christianity is put outside the realm of objective fact.  Therefore, when Christians appeal to the Bible as truth for all people at all times, our society does not see this as a truth claim but as a power grab.  And there, I think, is the crux of the paradox of Christianity thriving in North America while having so little actual influence.  It is important in people’s private lives, but has almost no impact on business, politics, science, economics and other public endeavors.

Pearcey points out that we need to learn the language and the worldview of our culture in order to be able to connect with it, just like missionaries and embassy staff do.  We also need to be able to analyze worldviews around us (as well as those we have absorbed into our own thoughts), and the best way to do so is to compare our the biblical message with what these worldviews say about

  • Creation (Where did it all come from?  Who are we and how did we get here?)
  • Fall (What has gone wrong with the world?)
  • Redemption (How can the world be set right again?)

Not only does this grid of Creation, Fall, and Redemption provide us with a simple and effective way of comparing worldviews, but it also explains why the biblical idea of Creation is under such relentless attack.  Creation, as first principle, is foundational and “critics of Christianity know that it stands or falls with its teaching on ultimate origins.”

The rest of the book is divided into two main parts,

  • challenging Darwinian thought from many angles and explaining the idea of Intelligent Design, and
  • outlining the history of evangelicalism and its surprising influence on American thought, including feminism.

Both sections are full of unexpected but well-documented concepts that challenge readers, from a discussion of the deliberate deception acknowledged and practiced by evolutionary scientists to the idea that feminism is directly related to the public/private split, mentioned above, that is so pervasive in both the evangelical and secular world.

Nancy Pearcey, “one of the brightest minds serving evangelical Christianity,” has skillfully combined many complex ideas into 400 pages of eminently readable, though intense, discussion.  The book itself is supported by another 100 pages of appendices, notes, book recommendations, and study guide.

Total Truth would be an excellent resource to equip teens for life in the world.  It is also an important book for parents and, indeed, all Christians to study.  I highly recommend it for your family, homeschool, and church.

This is the kind of book I would recommend for your teen’s science and math reading

This is yet another book in the in the 2014 52 Books in 52 Weeks Challenge and is also linked to Saturday Reviews, Works for Me Wednesdays, Booknificent Thursdays, Raising HomemakersFinishing Strong , and Trivium Tuesdays as well as the Carnival of Homeschooling and the Charlotte Mason Carnival.

Disclosure: I bought this book after having it repeatedly and enthusiastically recommended to me.  I am not compensated for this review in any way.


  1. hopeinbrazil says:

    Sounds like a terrific book. Thanks for reviewing it.

  2. Amy says:

    Yes, this sounds like it would be a great read!

  3. Thanks for sharing this book on Booknificent Thursday! Hope to see you again this week!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *