Tea Time with Annie Kate Rotating Header Image

Review: Martin Luther by Simonetta Carr

Very few people have had as great an influence on western civilization as Martin Luther.  Yet, it wasn’t Luther himself, and those who think only about the man miss so much.  Nor was Luther aiming to change civilization or even the church—no, Luther was a person gripped by the search for God’s forgiveness, whose eventual joy and relief spilled out into the whole world as he sought to glorify God.

Now, five hundred years after the beginning of the Reformation, much is being written about Luther and some of it misses the point, but Simonetta Carr’s excellent Martin Luther balances history, theology, and faith.

Beginning with young Luther’s home life and extensive schooling, Carr emphasizes his struggles to find peace with God.  Whether studying, confessing his sins, exceeding the monastery’s rules, teaching, or caring for the people in his charge, Luther was always concerned about God’s anger against sin.  When Pope Leo X tried to raise money by selling forgiveness, Luther objected, first in sermons and then in writing.  Unexpectedly, his scholarly protests were translated into German and his Ninety-Five Theses spread through Europe like wildfire, beginning the Reformation.

Carr’s beautifully illustrated book takes us from this event  500 years ago, through Luther’s struggles with the pope and the emperor, his kidnapping, Bible translation work, family life, and death.  She sums up her biography with these words, “While many others attacked the abuse and corruption of the church and of the pope, Luther went to the root of the problem, which is in man’s sinful heart, a problem that only God can solve.”

As always in the Christian Biographies for Young People series, Carr includes a timeline, various historical tidbits, and some of Luther’s writings.  And, as expected, this well-researched, carefully written, and carefully explained story melds theology and biography into one of the best introductions to Luther’s life and times.

Written for ages 7-12 but full enough of information, ideas, and illustrations to captivate teens and adults as well, Simonetta Carr’s Martin Luther is essential for your homeschool church history and history classes.  Because of Luther’s incredible impact on both civilization and religion, this excellent introduction to his life, beliefs, and legacy should be in all home, church, school, and public libraries, and I urge you to ensure that happens in your community.

2017 is the 500th anniversary of Luther’s Ninety-Five Theses, so a plethora of books is being published about him, and I am blessed to be able to review several of them.  This one is probably the best introduction to his life, times, theology, and influence.

If you enjoyed this article, you might want to follow me on Google+ where I often mention helpful or interesting ideas, or connect with me on GoodReads where I share what I read. 

Disclosure:  I received a review copy from Reformation Heritage Books.

This article may be linked to Finishing Strong ,Raising Homemakers, Saturday Reviews, Booknificent Thursdays.

First Frost and Autumn Thoughts

For a few days now we’ve been busily squirreling away garden goodies.  Although the various weather forecasts disagreed, the predicted temperatures were cool enough that we, in a valley, expected frost last night.  And, yes, we got it.

The garden was mostly covered with tarps and sheets, and it will be a few hours before we can assess the damage.  I expect that Miss 14’s lovely morning glories will be gone, and the few pumpkins that we could not protect will not ripen properly. First frosts can be spotty things, but judging by the even crunchiness of grass blades and uncovered squash leaves throughout our garden and yard, this one seems fairly consistent. 

With the enormous amount of rain we had this summer, our garden has produced well, on the whole, and we are thankful for the delicious, healthy food God has given us—cucumbers, beets, tomatoes, herbs, melons, garlic, onions, beans, squash, pumpkins, radishes, peppers, broccoli, and so much more. 

And now it is time to start thinking about fall, to harvest the rest of the garden, to treasure the golden days before the snow comes.  My husband has been chopping wood, the chimney cleaners are coming soon, and we have straw for the chickens in the winter.

Next week school begins.

I am not ready for any of this.  I do not see how it will be possible to manage all of this. 

So today, during rest breaks between all the other necessary work, I need to take some time to plan what to do, what to say no to, how to prioritize, and how to adjust our routine.  I need to ask God what it means, practically and right now, to love God with my whole being and to love those around me—family, friends, church, and various communities—as myself.  And then I need to organize my life so that those things will happen.

May God bless us all with wisdom as we prepare for the next season.  May he give us what we need to live for him in our everyday lives.

If you enjoyed this article, you might want to follow me on Google+ where I often mention helpful or interesting ideas, or connect with me on GoodReads where I  (eventually) share what I read. 

Review: The Unreformed Martin Luther by Andreas Malessa

2017 is the 500th anniversary of Luther’s Ninety-Five Theses, so a plethora of books is being published about him, and I am blessed to be able to review several of them.  This one is the most surprising and original.

In The Unreformed Martin Luther, German journalist and theologian Andreas Malessa took an unusual approach.  He collected popular stories and sayings about Luther and evaluated each of them using Luther’s own copious writings as well as contemporary records and later discussions, some scholarly.

This book contains a few startling revelations.  For example, Luther sent out three copies of the Ninety-Five Theses but most likely did not actually nail them to the cathedral door.  Besides that surprising suggestion, Malessa also clarifies Luther’s doctrine and defends his lifestyle—and, no, Luther was not a drunk.

Malessa excels in putting Luther’s life into its historical context, and as such The Unreformed Martin Luther contains several illuminating accounts of customs, practices, and assumptions of the day that help us understand both Luther and the Reformation better. How marriages were legalized in those days, for example, was a revelation to me.

Filled with humorous tidbits, careful explanations of theology, and much historical context, The Unreformed Martin Luther strips away myths surrounding this great man and presents him, respectfully and, hopefully honestly, as a good man.  This book is centered completely on Luther, the man, and his impact on the world, and does not discuss at all how God worked through him.  As such it is almost a secular book, even though it is about one of the main events of Christianity and presents Luther’s theology accurately.

The Unreformed Martin Luther ends most abruptly with a chapter on Luther’s anti-Semitism which is, obviously, a very important factor to a modern German author but certainly not adequate as a conclusion.  Without a conclusion or any reference to God’s work in and through Luther, the book seems little more than a compendium of articles about a great man, interesting but not very satisfying.

If you only have time to read one book about Luther, I would not recommend this one, either for your homeschool or for pleasure.  (Simonetta Carr’s Martin Luther, to be reviewed next week is probably the best introduction for young people and adults, and Luther The Leader by Virgil Robinson is an excellent read aloud. )  However, if you already know about this great man, The Unreformed Martin Luther will provide a completely different approach and will give you some new ideas to consider.

Much of our homeschool church history learning (link to my reviews) is based on biographies, historical fiction, and primary source documents.

If you enjoyed this article, you might want to follow me on Google+ where I often mention helpful or interesting ideas, or connect with me on GoodReads where I  (eventually) share what I read. 

Disclosure:  I received a review copy of this book from Kregel Books and have given our honest opinions.  I am not compensated for them.

A Summer of Total Truth

This summer some dear ladies and I studied our way, together, through Nancy Pearcey’s Total Truth.

Never have I seen so much enthusiasm about a book besides the Bible.  One of the ladies was still reading the introduction when she decided to buy her agnostic father a copy.  Another one related how every significant conversation the previous week had involved this book.  One explained how, during one section, she turned each page hesitantly, wondering what she would have to repent of next.  And at least one husband was so deeply involved that the couple almost needed to buy an extra copy; another husband did not have to read it at all because the wife shared what she was reading, step by step.  It was shared with children and friends, and it changed our lives.

Not to say that Total Truth is an easy read.  We were all overwhelmed at times; even I was, though I’d read it twice before.  One of the ladies said she was planning to reread it in the future, after she had bought a better dictionary.  Another one is starting over immediately to be able to absorb it better.  I’m hoping to reread it soon to try to figure out a way to make it accessible to teens.  So, no, it is not easy to read, but we have found it to be worth every bit of effort.

So, what is Total Truth all about?  I described it in an earlier review, but here is what I took from it this time:

North American Christianity is more about individual salvation than about the effect of Christianity on the culture, and this negative reality has significant roots as well as significant results.

  • First Pearcey describes the two-level split we live by.  Our society assumes there is a fact-based area of public truth (science, materialism, etc.) and a subjective area of religion, art, and values.  She outlines where this idea came from, how it applies to various aspects of our world, its devastating effects, and how we can understand various other worldviews.
  • Next she points out how our beliefs about origins affect everything else; she discusses problems with Darwinism, quoting accepted secular scientific journals. She also presents the idea that the universe is obviously and undoubtedly designed by a greater being, pointing out that this is the only way to overcome such a split in our lives and society.
  • Then she discusses the history of evangelicalism, showing how much of our secular society today, including the two-level split, is related to non-biblical ideas accepted unquestioningly during the Great Awakenings, and how they apply to our families as well.
  • Finally she points out that the goal of understanding the culture around us is to learn to live close to God, identifying and forsaking our personal idols and really learning to live by the truth that we can do nothing apart from God.  In this way we will be able to reach out into our culture as ‘worldview missionaries,’ explaining our faith in ways that others will be able to understand.

We struggled through the thirteen chapters in three months.  We had intense discussions, interspersed with laughter and encouragement, and learned much about God, this world, and ourselves.  I often felt as though this book were taking up my whole summer, but what a good use of a summer it has been!  How grateful I am for this opportunity!

As I was discussing Total Truth with friends, one of them, who knows Nancy Pearcey personally, said that she is not only ‘a brilliant mind’ but also a godly person who lives what she writes about.  Someday in heaven, perhaps even sooner, I will meet this woman who has taught and encouraged so many by using her talents to God’s glory, sacrificing her own ambitions on the altar of obedience.  Then I will be able to say a personal thank you.

Until then, I thank my earthly father, who handed out copies of this book to whomever would take one, the dear ladies who were willing to study it with me, and our heavenly Father  who gave insight to the author and helped her, and us, learn to love him with our intellects as well as our hearts.

May we all learn to give up the idols of our hearts (Ezekiel 14:1-11), may God give each of us a heart of flesh (Ezekiel 11:14-21), and may we learn to boast only in the Lord (1 Corinthians 1:18-31).  For, as Jesus said, “Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit, for apart from me you can do nothing.”  (John 15:5b)

Soli deo Gloria—to God alone be the glory.  Amen.

If you enjoyed this article, you might want to follow me on Google+ where I often mention helpful or interesting ideas, or connect with me on GoodReads where I share what I read. 

This is yet another book in the in the 2017 52 Books in 52 Weeks Challenge and is also linked to Saturday Reviews, Booknificent Thursdays, Literacy Musings Monday, Raising Homemakers, and The Book Nook

Review: High as the Heavens by Kate Breslin

Evelyn Marche, British nurse in WW1 Brussels, had taken over Edith Clavell’s hospital, even winning an Iron Cross for saving the life of a German major.  Now she directed the hospital during the day while in the evenings, she helped her aunt and uncle run a café frequented by the Germans. In her few remaining hours she used what she learned in the hospital and the café to support the Belgian resistance.

While on the way to a resistance assignment, Eve arrived first at a plane crash and was stunned to recognize the injured British airman as Captain Simon Forrester.  How much circumstances had changed since she last saw him, and how much she had changed! Even so, she was determined to save his life, no matter what the cost, but she also had to rescue her long-lost brother and sister, protect her mother, carry out injured Simon’s dangerous assignment, and live with the demons of her past.

Kate Breslin’s novel is difficult to put down.  She has woven a net of espionage that is peopled with vulnerable and believable characters.  There is drama, courage, deception, and even romance.  Central to the book is Kate’s struggle with her past.  Can God really forgive what she did in a moment of terror?  Can her husband forgive her?  Is there mercy even for her?

Miss 14 warned me that this novel would be too stressful for me.  It certainly had many intense moments and continues to have an impact, but it has not left me sleepless at night.  The comforting message echoed in the title of the book, that God’s love is as ‘high as the heavens’ made all the difference.

If you have some free time available for a gripping war story, I recommend High as the Heavens.

This summer I am reading a lot of Miss 14’s style of books, hoping to be able to enjoy and discuss them together.  Perhaps this will even be an opportunity to compare styles of writing and discuss both literary and biblical standards of excellence.

If you enjoyed this review, you might want to follow me on Google+ where I often mention helpful or interesting ideas, or connect with me on GoodReads where I share what I read. 

This is yet another book in the in the 2017 52 Books in 52 Weeks Challenge and is also linked to Saturday Reviews, Booknificent Thursdays, Literacy Musings Monday, and The Book Nook

Disclosure: This book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc. and is available at your favorite bookseller from Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group.